Skip to main content
4,355+ Five-Star ReviewsComparison GuideSanta Fe Springs, CA

Screen Printing vs DTG Printing

Choosing between screen printing and direct-to-garment (DTG) printing? The right method depends on your order size, design complexity, budget, and timeline. This guide breaks down everything you need to know so you can make the best decision for your custom apparel project.

Trusted by the world’s best brands

DisneyGoogleSpotifyUFCRed BullSonyWarner BrosNickelodeonFoxBETLA RamsAudibleGettyPlayboyASUSNeweggFrito-LayPBRTuro88risingBoys & Girls ClubF45

At a Glance

Screen Printing vs DTG: Quick Comparison

Here is how the two most popular t-shirt printing methods stack up across the factors that matter most.

Screen Printing DTG Printing
Minimum Order24 piecesNo minimum (1+)
Max ColorsUp to 8 (per screen)Unlimited (full color)
Best ForBulk orders, simple designsSmall runs, photo-realistic art
DurabilityExcellent (50+ washes)Very good (30-50 washes)
Fabric CompatibilityMost fabricsCotton & cotton blends only
Setup Fee$25/color/screenNone
Print FeelSmooth, slight texture on fabricSoft, ink absorbed into fabric

Best Scenarios

When to Choose Screen Printing

Screen printing is the gold standard for bulk custom apparel. Choose it when:

You need 24 or more pieces of the same design
Your design uses 1-4 solid colors (not photographic)
You want the lowest possible per-unit cost at scale
Durability is critical (workwear, uniforms, resale)
You are printing on dark or polyester fabrics

Learn more about screen printing

Best Scenarios

When to Choose DTG Printing

DTG excels at full-color, low-quantity, and detail-heavy projects. Choose it when:

You need fewer than 24 pieces or just a sample
Your design has gradients, photos, or unlimited colors
You need a faster turnaround than screen printing allows
You want no setup fees or screen charges
Each shirt has a different design (names, numbers, variations)

Learn more about DTG printing

Cost Breakdown

Cost Comparison by Quantity

The per-unit cost of each method changes dramatically with order size. Here is where the crossover happens.

1-23 pieces

DTG wins

No setup fees make DTG the clear choice for small runs.

24-50 pieces

Crossover zone

Both methods are competitive. Decision depends on colors and complexity.

50+ pieces

Screen printing wins

Per-unit cost drops fast. At 200+, screen printing is 40-60% cheaper.

Not sure about your quantity?

Our estimate tool calculates exact pricing for both methods so you can compare side by side.

Try the Quote Calculator

Quality & Feel

Durability, Feel, and Vibrancy

Both methods produce professional results, but they differ in how the ink bonds with the fabric.

Screen Printing Quality

  • Durability: Ink cures at 320F, creating a plastic bond that withstands 50+ washes
  • Vibrancy: Opaque inks pop on dark fabrics. PMS color matching available
  • Feel: Slight texture on fabric. Discharge inks available for a softer hand
  • Best finish: Bold, vibrant, consistent across hundreds of pieces

DTG Quality

  • Durability: Water-based ink bonds with cotton fibers. Lasts 30-50 washes
  • Vibrancy: Excellent on light fabrics. Can print on dark with white underbase
  • Feel: Virtually no texture. Ink is absorbed into fibers for a soft hand
  • Best finish: Photo-realistic detail, soft feel, retail-quality prints

Common Questions

Screen Printing vs DTG FAQ

Answers to the questions we hear most when customers are deciding between screen printing and DTG.

Which lasts longer, screen printing or DTG?
Screen printing generally lasts longer. The ink sits on top of the fabric and creates a thick, durable layer that can withstand 50+ washes without significant fading. DTG ink is absorbed into the fibers, which gives a softer feel but may fade slightly faster after 30-50 washes. Both methods produce long-lasting results when properly cured.
Is DTG cheaper than screen printing?
It depends on quantity. DTG is cheaper for small orders (under 24 pieces) because there are no setup fees. Screen printing becomes significantly cheaper per piece at higher quantities because the setup cost is spread across more shirts. The crossover point is typically around 24-50 pieces.
Can you screen print a photograph on a shirt?
Screen printing is not ideal for photographs because each color requires a separate screen. A process called simulated process printing can reproduce photos using 6-8 screens, but it is expensive and complex. DTG is the better choice for photographic or highly detailed full-color artwork.
Does DTG work on polyester?
Standard DTG printing works best on 100% cotton or high-cotton blends (at least 50% cotton). Polyester and performance fabrics require special pretreatment and may not hold DTG ink well. For polyester, we recommend screen printing or DTF (direct-to-film) printing instead.
How many colors can I use with screen printing?
Most screen printing orders use 1-4 colors. Each additional color adds a screen setup fee ($25/screen). We can print up to 8 colors, but beyond 4 colors, DTG often becomes more cost-effective because it prints unlimited colors at no extra charge.
Which method has a softer feel on the shirt?
DTG printing has a softer hand feel because the water-based ink is absorbed directly into the cotton fibers. Screen printing sits on top of the fabric and has a slightly raised texture. However, we use discharge and water-based screen printing inks that produce a very soft feel on light-colored garments.
Can I mix screen printing and DTG in the same order?
Yes! Many customers use screen printing for the front (a simple logo) and DTG for the back (a detailed, full-color design). We can also use screen printing for the bulk order and DTG for a small run of specialty pieces. Contact us to discuss a hybrid approach.
What is the turnaround time for each method?
Turnaround for both methods depends on order size, design complexity, and our current production schedule. DTG is typically faster than screen printing for small orders since there are no screens to set up. Rush options may be available case-by-case for both methods.

Not Sure Which Method to Choose? We Will Help.

Tell us about your project and our team will recommend the best printing method, garment, and pricing for your exact needs. Free quotes, no obligation.

Free Quote